Meta Description:
The FDA has announced a recall of more than 80,000 Keurig coffee pods due to a labeling issue. Learn how to identify the recalled McCafé decaf K-Cups and what to do if you have them.
FDA Announces Recall of Keurig Coffee Pods
If you rely on decaf coffee to start your day, it may be time to check your pantry. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has announced a recall involving more than 80,000 Keurig coffee pods sold across select U.S. states. The recall affects McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods that may contain full-caffeine coffee instead of decaf.
The recall was initiated by Keurig Dr Pepper in December 2025 and later classified by the FDA as a Class II recall. This classification means that consuming the product could cause temporary or medically reversible health effects, especially for people sensitive to caffeine.
Why Were McCafé Decaf K-Cups Recalled?
The recalled Keurig coffee pods were labeled as “decaf,” but testing revealed that some pods may actually contain regular, full-caffeine coffee. This labeling error can be a concern for people who avoid caffeine due to health conditions, pregnancy, sleep issues, or dietary restrictions.
It is important to note that this recall is not related to contamination or product quality. The coffee itself is safe to drink for most people, but the incorrect labeling creates a potential health risk for specific consumers.
How to Identify the Recalled Keurig Coffee Pods
The recalled product is McCafé Premium Roast Decaf Coffee K-Cup Pods sold in 84-count cartons. These products were distributed in California, Indiana, and Nevada.
You can identify the recalled cartons using the details below:
| Product Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Product Name | McCafé Premium Roast Decaf K-Cup Pods |
| Carton Size | 84-count |
| Best-By Date | 17 NOV 2026 |
| Batch Number | 5101564894 |
| Material Number | 5000358463 |
| ASIN | B07GCNDL91 |
| Distribution States | California, Indiana, Nevada |
If your carton matches these details, it is part of the recall.
What Should You Do If You Have the Recalled Pods?
If you are actively monitoring your caffeine intake, it is best not to consume the recalled McCafé decaf K-Cups. You should either throw the pods away or return them to the place of purchase. Keurig is offering a full refund or replacement for affected products.
If caffeine intake is not a concern for you, no action is strictly required. The recall was issued due to a labeling issue, not because the coffee is unsafe. However, you still have the right to return the product if you prefer genuine decaf coffee.
Why This Recall Matters
Product recalls like this highlight the importance of accurate labeling, especially for food and beverages. Many consumers depend on clear information to manage their health safely. Similar recalls in the past have shown how small errors can have wide-reaching effects.
For more updates on food safety, product recalls, and consumer alerts, check our related recall coverage and food safety updates in the blog.
Staying informed helps you make better choices. If you drink decaf regularly, taking a moment to check your Keurig coffee pods could save you from unwanted caffeine intake.